Terminated Dealers’ Legal Fight ‘Unique’

Monday, April 16, 2012 | Lillie Guyer, WardsAuto

It is billed as a one-of-a-kind legal issue, but as with many court proceedings it is becoming one thing after another.

The issue centers on suits filed by Chrysler and General Motors dealers who lost their franchises in 2009.

They contend their constitutional rights were violated when the auto makers dropped retailers as part of a government bailout and post-bankruptcy plan.

The lawsuits contend the federal government violated the Fifth Amendment, which says private property shall not be taken for public use without just compensation.

“This case is unique, one of a kind,” says Richard Faulkner of a Texas law firm representing 96 dealers. “Nothing quite like this litigation has been pursued, because the U.S. government has never stolen people's property like this before.”

“Extremely important development,” says dealer
attorney Leonard Bellavia.
In a dealer-packed courtroom, Judge Robert H. Hodges Jr. recently denied government motions to dismiss dealer cases in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims in Washington.

“Dealers are ecstatic,” Faulkner says of the ruling.

The court on April 12 further denied the government’s motion to reconsider the case. This means the government must answer the class action suits, dealer lawyers say.

Meanwhile in Detroit, U.S. District Judge Sean Cox ruled Chrysler dealers who lost their franchises but got them back after winning arbitration cases don’t have the right to reopen at their original locations. He also said dealers were not entitled to financial compensation for damages.

The Texas-based lawsuit seeks up to $4 billion in damages. A New York suit on behalf of 75 dealers nationwide seeks at least $200 million.

Judge Hodges’s refusal to dismiss the case “is an extremely important development,” says Leonard Bellavia, an attorney in the New York lawsuit.

Were it not for that ruling, “the case would be dead,” says Nancie Marzulla, a Washington attorney representing dealers.

She calls the case a first. “It raises the larger issue of who picks up the pieces for the losers when the federal government clearly and explicitly is picking the winners.”
Dealer lawyers expect discovery issues to take most of this year. They anticipate a possible hearing on merits by late 2012 or early 2013.

Win or lose for either side, the case could end up in federal appeals court, says California attorney Harry Zanville, who represents dealers with Faulkner.

Bellavia foresees it ultimately going before the U.S. Supreme Court.

In his ruling, Judge Hodges says, “The question of what constitutes a ‘taking’ for purposes of the Fifth Amendment has proved to be a problem of considerable difficulty.”

He adds, “Plaintiffs should have the opportunity to develop a case that may turn out to be unique.”




Monthly Dealer Representation Program
This is the most acclaimed program in the industry for franchised dealers who would like one of the most experienced dealership law firms in the country to be their “in-house” counsel on a daily basis. For a low monthly fee of $300, dealership employees have unlimited access to BBAC attorneys on all dealership issues.
Learn More

Find out the five (5) reasons why doing this in-house will cost you far more than retaining the law firm with a national reputation in warranty parts reimbursement.

CALL US: 516-873-3000!

Dealer Gets Court Order Preventing Bank From Terminating Floor Plan
A floor plan lending institution threatened to terminate its floor plan relationship with an automobile dealership client. The basis upon...
Columbia-Greene Media
Thursday, October 27, 2016
Local Ford Dealer Battles To Save Dealership Started By Henry Ford
A Grand Gorge car dealership in business for more than 80 years is at risk of losing its Ford... MORE
Automotive News
Tuesday, July 12, 2016
VW has agreed to pay billions to diesel owners. Did retailers miss out?
The hundreds of frustrated Volkswagen dealers who turned up at the National Automobile Dealers... MORE
Press Release
Thursday, June 30, 2016
Bellavia Blatt Announces Class Action Lawsuit Against
Bellavia Blatt & Crossett, P.C. ("Bellavia Blatt"), a law firm that represents thousands of... MORE
Automotive Buy Sell Report
Tuesday, April 12, 2016
When Nissan Plays Favorites, Dealership Buyers and Sellers Suffer
A recent article published by Automotive News about incentives Nissan pays "favored" dealers to... MORE
Press Release
Thursday, October 8, 2015
Leading Dealership Law Attorney Questions Timing of Initial Public Offering of Ferrari
Says Automaker's Parent Company May Have Inflated Sales Figures before Planning to Spin off... MORE
Press Release
Friday, September 11, 2015
Over 200 Former Chrysler Dealers Defeat Obama Administration's Latest Motion to Dismiss Wrongful "Takings" Lawsuit
Bellavia Blatt & Crossett, P.C. ("Bellavia Blatt"), a law firm that specializes in representing... MORE
Bellavia Blatt & Crossett, PC has offices in Long Island, Manhattan, Albany and New Jersey    |     Contact Us
BGA - DealerLaw on Facebook BGA - DealerLaw on Twitter BGA - DealerLaw on Linked-In